Need immediate assistance? Contact us on WhatsApp +1 (617) 319-8767

Why Amazon Rejects Your Appeals: 3 Costly Mistakes Keeping Sellers Suspended 

It’s Q4 (as you may have heard) and it’s an excellent time of year to make sure you’re avoiding Amazon account mistakes as often as possible! In a recent article, I offered a rundown of a few of the main mistakes we have observed brand owners making on their Amazon accounts, that cost them time, money, and sometimes, their sanity.

As there are many ways you could trip yourself up, then watch Amazon take you down, you’ll want to be extra vigilant against any ASIN-level takedowns or unresolved policy warnings which could lead to worse consequences. Who wants an account suspension at this time of year? Or, ever? 

Since policy enforcement and performance evaluation teams (my former teams) require sufficient assessments and strong appeals to justify a reinstatement, you can’t demonstrate an unwillingness to take the process seriously.  

If you look out of your element, unaware of appeal trends, or disengaged from the types of factual, data-driven material Amazon needs to see, you get stuck in what I call the “denial cycle.” 

That’s when Amazon investigators repeatedly deny appeals, making their peers much more likely to deny you again when you try again, resubmitting over and over to no avail. 

Do what you can to avoid listing errors, buyer confusion or item quality complaints, of course.  But whatever you do, please don’t compound the original mistake that flagged your account for deactivation by sending in haphazard appeals. Amazon will punish you for that, either by ignoring them, answering with generic copy and paste, or annotating the account that you’re not submitting any useful info worth reading. Either way, they won’t be reinstating you.

Below, I take you through the biggest errors we see brand owners making that limit their Amazon sales and hinder their abilities to heal their wounds. During Q4 especially, it takes some time to get reviewed properly, to receive a reply indicative of a real response, and to get reinstated.

While I realize that Amazon queues and teams get backlogged from days to weeks during this period, very few Amazon-based businesses can survive that degree of damage. No sellers that we work with could ever survive seeing their Amazon account suspended for a long time.

Keep in mind, any nuanced or complex matters may require more than one team, or more than one person at Amazon, to review the details properly. They’ll need a chance to do that and reply back.

Mistake #1 — Hurrying, or Panicking, or Firing Off an Appeal just to “Get it Done”

Sounds straightforward right? Haste makes waste.  Still, I need to make sure I state it plainly.

Are you in Amazon’s Account Health program? If you are, Amazon's Account Health teams give sellers a “heads up” call or message about potential account suspensions. You have 72 hours to prepare a convincing dispute, if you want to challenge the findings they based their investigation on, or an appeal, but only if you’re accepting fault and providing definitive solutions to fix problems.

If you have no ability to dispute a policy violation and your appeals fail, Amazon will often deactivate the account. And sometimes, they will reinstate you only if you disprove the accuracy of that action, and prove to them that they were wrong to suspend you.

And if you’re not in AHA, Account Health Assurance, you may need to appeal it even sooner. 

This fairly tight deadline (especially if they hit you with this on a Friday afternoon) may lead sellers to panic and to send in badly written appeals. Worse, they may copy another seller’s work or “AI- it” based on what popular AI tools tell them others have done before them. Investigators can tell, too.

Since panicky drafts often lead straight to a denial and lack the relevant details to reinstate, you can’t really hope to get a sympathetic ear or a good outcome. 

Treating this as an unpleasant exercise to get over with as soon as possible delivers you into the hands of an investigator who is eager to glance it over, deny it, get credit for working it, and move on. Denying an appeal is quicker, and a lot easier, than reading through for each component necessary in order to reinstate.

Once you build a pile of rejections, account investigators stop reading the appeals entirely, and don’t need to justify spending more time on it. Don’t give them an excuse to ignore you! Even if they do manage to annotate their reasons why it’s denied, you don’t want them to leave comments about a hard to follow, incomplete or unacceptable appeal.

Instead, begin a solid outline towards an appeal draft even if you only have a couple of hours to focus on it. Yes, I understand that an outline does not represent a comprehensive approach to appeal writing, but keep in mind that the person on the Amazon side who reads it and decides your fate only needs one reason to reject you. If they find one early on, they don’t bother to read the rest of the appeal.  

Generic, subpar content simply hurts your overall odds of success.  Go ahead and speak with Account Health reps after you get denied, but take their opinions with a grain of salt. They don’t always have THE answer, they may only offer THEIR take on it.  The gulf between what Amazon needs to reinstate you, and what an AHS rep gives as advice, may differ.

Since you don’t want to wait for several days and lose tons of revenue before you submit an appeal, think of how you can accommodate their timeline AND include the actual details they need in order to maintain your selling privileges.

If they stop replying entirely, the problem becomes two-fold. One, they are more likely not to bother reading it, and two, if investigators see a long series of denials, they’re just joining their peers in agreeing that you’re not fit for reinstatement. The hill becomes that much steeper to climb.

Mistake #2 – Using bad appeal formats, Emailing Jeff or Andy, or sending in POAs

Bottom line: Don’t submit a Plan of Action, if they didn’t tell you it’s required to reinstate!

Even now, we see long, convoluted POAs sent via Seller Central petitioning for reinstatement.  Often, they’ve already been told that their only way out of a policy violation-based suspension is a dispute, properly formatted and detailed. Instead, they see an appeal divided into sections declared as “Root Causes” and “immediate remediation steps” and “future prevention” which uses the classic outdated format of yesteryear. Those Plans of Action get to someone who won’t even read it, once they see the format is totally wrong.  

Even worse, many sellers use long paragraphs defending themselves or use fluff to make it longer, as if that’s more convincing. Others put the appeal on company letterhead to create an illusion of seriousness and formality.

Amazon isn’t impressed.  If Amazon doesn’t even want a POA, but you gave them one anyway, you know the result in advance. Due to AI suggestions or someone you met somewhere at a seller event, it won’t matter. It just serves to set you up to take a fall.  

Don’t hand Amazon opportunities to ignore you: they’ll take you up on it every time. 

If you lack acceptable documentation, be it testing documents, compliance paperwork or even info on your manufacturer, don’t appeal at all until you have it.  Otherwise, you may be wasting time focusing on appeal language when you could have devoted more time to gathering that material they truly need in order to accept you back on. Think before you send.

Mistake #3 – Generic AI, will displease and dissuade a human investigator

I talk about sellers submitting poorly composed AI appeals a lot because those often share the same flaws the generic templates lawyers and amateurs always did, which led straight to the rubbish bin. Based on what we see lately,  it deserves yet another mention, because unedited, barely logical AI slop dissuades Amazon’s appeal review teams from reading it. 

Generic statements that don’t present an actual process or solution discourage reinstatement, and making promises without demonstrating HOW you’ll actually execute those solutions just takes up space. 

If you promise “automated monitoring” or “advanced internal systems” they’ll of course wonder what exactly you mean, why you included it, and why it’s relevant. If it’s not readily clear, they’ll assume you got it from AI and just slapped it in there because it looked or sounds good.

If you provide corrective actions that sound responsible and specific, but can’t be verified against Amazon’s own data or in any other way, it’s just an empty vague reference, too.  Any process to implement new strategies must reference already executed steps that you tested for success, AND they speak to the concerns Amazon flagged before. 

Just as all “template mill” services with copy and paste-styled content failed miserably, the newer AI versions do too for the same reasons.  Submitting generic content doesn’t have any value. 

If anything, it’s a surefire way to waste Amazon’s time. They tend not to like that very much, and you’re the one who stands to be punished. Not an investigator failing to take you seriously.

When Amazon asks you to appeal using specific proof, data, and details that will prove your ASIN or account problems don’t exist, take advantage of that opportunity by disputing it. 

We won’t quote directly (yet) from copious and faulty AI slop work we see each day, but ask yourself how copying and pasting any language will impress Amazon.  If you just add links to policy pages with no real proof to address your understanding of and obedience with them,  or you say “we have revamped our training manuals” without granular specifics, you’re wasting appeals opportunities.  It will look and sound like AI, and they know it’s 70-80% AI, so,  they toss it.

In conclusion, whether sellers choose at the outset to pursue their own reinstatement or they decide to hire a service, the song stays the same: Amazon won’t accept poor appeals.  

If you’re paying for a service, don’t accept amateur-level work that is no better than what you can do yourself. If your appeals fail to produce results, don’t just get together “escalations” that aren’t really escalations at all. In fact, they often reek of desperation and fall on deaf ears.

It’ll only compound past mistakes and turn them off. Since “amateur hour” Plan of Action templates can be spotted a mile away, Amazon will be convinced only that you don’t know what you’re doing and the appeal isn’t worth reading. Don’t do more harm than good to your odds!

We’re always available to take a look, before you revise and resubmit. Reach out to us.